Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief – Olympus Reimagined

I made the acquaintance of Harry Potter’s successor today: Percy Jackson. The similarities between the two – one a franchise nearing its end and the other a franchise in the making – are pretty obvious. But now we’re on a different scale. We’ve moved away from the dark hidden London alleys, middle class suburbia and Scottish castles and lochs. Now we’re in Olympian territory, complete with a very unpleasant visit to the Underworld, ruled over, a little bizarrely, by Steve Coogan and his grumpy wife. However, there’s not much that’s Greek about this Olympian universe – Mount Olympus is at the end of a golden lift ride in the Empire State Building, the Parthenon is in Tennessee and the entrance to Hades is under the Hollywood sign.

There is a lot in Percy Jackson and The Lightning Thief to enjoy, especially watching Logan Lerman take on the lead role. But, for me, it felt like too much was packed in, just to prove that the storywriters had read up on their classics (or at least seen Clash of the Titans). We had a harpy, a cow-throwing minotaur (surprisingly easy to dispose of), a hydra, a leather-clad Medusa, lotus-feeding temptresses, not too mention centaurs, satyrs, heroes and the quarrelsome (and rather pretty) gods themselves.

It’s difficult to complain about a 40-foot Sean Bean as Zeus or the charismatic, the always excellent Kevin McKidd as Poseidon, cenotaur Piece Brosnan, except to say that there was not enough of them. And that was completely opposite to how I felt about the baddie of the piece, Luke, the son of Hermes, who, Heavens knows how, stole the Lighting Bolt from under Zeus’ enormous nose. And then Luke hid this flashy tool inside the shield he gave to Percy, which Percy used frequently throughout the story. The final battle was unexciting and uninteresting. It could have been easily sacrificed for more time on the peak of Mount Olympus.

My biggest complaint, though, was the misuse of the excellent actress Catherine Keener who, very definitely, was absent in spirit throught this film. They might as well have had a cardboard cutout – or borrowed one of those dummies from Surrogates. Steve Coogan may also have needed a nudge. Uma Thurman, by contrast, seemed to enjoy her meaty role.

I’m wondering how the hydra, turned to stone, was explained away.

I left an extremely packed cinema thinking that I would definitely want to see a sequel and that I would probably enjoy it more. The leads are likeable, just as they are in Harry Potter. I am also looking forward to seeing the remade Clash of the Titans this Spring – if only to see Medusa in 3D. It will be interesting to compare the two.

3 Responses to Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief – Olympus Reimagined

  1. Paul H says:

    I totally agree about the misuse of Catherine Keener’s talents. I would hope that if there are sequels, she could be allowed to craft a more positive and powerful character, which she is undoubtedly able to do, but I have no idea if the director would be receptive to such an uidea. 😦

    I became very impressed by Logan Lerman’s work in “My One and Only,” and also “3:10 to Yuma.” He won the Screen Actor’s Guild’s “Young Actor” award three times in four years. This is clearly someone with a lot of talent and drive and enthusiasm. In an interview, he said that if the Spiderman reboot was offered to him, he would be very interested in it. I read some of the user comments for that interview, and I noted that some felt [Anton Yelchin] would be better as Spiderman. I adore Yelchin, and would prefer him, but the new “Star Trek” franchise is going to suck up a lot of his time and energy for the foreseeable future. Lerman might actually have a shot.

    I liked what Pierce Brosnan brought to the role of Mr. Brunner/Chiron the Centaur. The special effects were fantastic in making a centaur seem real. Great special effects all around.

    I liked the way Athena’s daughter had blue eyes that almost glowed.

    And what can I say about Uma Thurman as Medusa? Absolutely fantastic. The filmmakers are said to feel that no sequels qill be considered unless this movie grosses at least a hundred million. They’re almost halfway there already, though: forty million in just the first weekend. Frankly, I enjoy movies based on Greek mythology. “Clash of the Titans” was great, for instance.

  2. WDW says:

    Hi Paul! Good to see you here. How I agree with wht you say about Catherine Keener. If Percy does return, and I think he will, I hope it’s without the mother.

    The special effects were very good and in their place. It was good to see Pierce Brosnan in that role. I would have liked more Zeus and Poseidon, and to have seen Athena interact with her daughter. I noticed the eyes – there were some stunning eyes in this film.

    Uma Thurman was superb as Medusa! I’m interested to see how Medusa in the new Clash of the Titans compares.

    That’s interesting about the hndred million goal. I think they’ll be a sequel and I think it will be better that this, the first. I enjoyed it much more than I thought I would.

    The original Clash of the Titans was fantastic!

  3. been says:

    Logan Lerman is another gorgeous young Jewish actor. He’s the next Tony Curtis.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s